Tuesday, November 22, 2011
"And everyone died. The end."
So I guess the only thing I don’t get about Seasons of Migration is the reason for all of Mustafa’s girlfriends’ committing suicide (it’s only the main premise of the book and all…). From what I can gather, Mustafa and the narrator are leading parallel lives, a pattern which obviously ends when Mustafa dies, leaving us to see if the narrator’s story will end in the same way. When Mustafa’s wife, who was entrusted to the care of the narrator dies, it is to say he carries on the same pattern of “love” ending in death. The book ends with the narrator diverting from Mustafa’s path in that he makes the conscious decision to live whereas Mustafa apparently chose death. What I don’t understand is the reason for all the suicides or how it connects to post colonialism (because post colonialism is always the answer, duh.) I suppose the women all felt a lack of emotional response from Mustafa, Mustafa felt guilt either about this or his aiding in Jean Morris’ death, and the narrator felt guilt for the death of Mustafa’s wife which all fueled the self-loathing that led to so many deaths but this still doesn’t give a postcolonial explanation. In any case, this was actually my favorite of the books that we read, despite the fact that I didn’t understand it and everyone in it should have been staying in a padded room…
Friday, November 11, 2011
Crazy Indian dads...
In our last discussion of White Teeth, everyone was pretty hard on
Samad for being a hypocrite about becoming westernized, which is
understandable. I mean, the guy yells at his wife for wearing tennis shoes with
her sari while he’s wearing a full track suit (if you're going to make arguments like that, at least make sure you're the epitome of Bangladeshi fashion). But
despite all this, I feel pretty sympathetic towards him. You have to consider
the idea that coming from the Bangladeshi/Indian culture (which has remained
mostly unchanged for centuries) to the western/English culture would be
terrifying, especially in the sense of parenting. Everyone has ideals and
values they want to instill in their children, and they do so, consciously or
not. For Samad, raising two already very impressionable boys in a comparatively
wild and secular culture would be a huge burden of responsibility, especially
considering he is, despite his resistance, influenced by it too. I guess part
of the reason I can’t be too tough on Samad is because his attitude reminds me
a little of my grandfather’s. My dad is from Singapore and his parents were
originally from Kerala, India. When he married my mom, an American, they kept
it a secret for a while because my grandfather was accustomed to the idea of arranging
marriages for one’s children and wasn't exactly thrilled at first with my dad making his own decision there (all 7 of his kids ended up choosing their own
spouses, so he didn’t really get to follow through on that one at all…). The thing is,
what my grandfather was doing was out of love for his kids, wanting to ensure
that they would live happy and productive lives, which is the same motive Samad
has. Sending Magid back home isn’t just about avoiding westernizing culture, it’s
about keeping at least one of his kids out of harm’s way and trying to ensure
him a good future. Seeing this, I really can’t get too angry with Samad. But that
still doesn’t justify kidnapping kids. That’s not the solution… usually…
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)